Punta Gorda officer, police chief charged in citizen academy shooting death

- The officer who is believed to have accidentally shot and killed a retired librarian during a citizens academy 'shoot, don't shoot' exercise has been charged with manslaughter, according to arresting documents. 

Officer Lee Coel, as well as the Punta Gorda Chief of Police Tom Lewis were arrested Wednesday. Lewis was charged with culpable negligence, according to the state attorney's office and WINK News

After the charges were announced, Coel turned himself in to the Charlotte County Jail. Lewis will not be arrested and has a court date of April 5. 

The charges come after the state attorney's review of an investigation into the shooting death of Mary Knowlton, which was conducted by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. 

After the shooting in August, Lewis called the 73-year-old woman's death a “horrific accident.”

Shooting at the Academy:

It happened during a roll-playing exercise designed to give citizens an idea of the life-and-death situations officers face. Mary Knowlton volunteered to play the role of a police officer during the demonstration, while Coel played the bad guy. His gun should have been loaded with blanks, but Knowlton was hit with a live round. She died shortly afterward at the hospital.

Lewis said after the shooting that he would not resign, but vowed to make changes to department procedures.

The Victim:

Knowlton's family filed a civil suit against the police department and the city approved a more than $2 million settlement in November.

Mary Knowlton was described as a life-long learner who was active in her church, volunteered in community organizations and at the local library.

Her niece, Stephanie Gary said she always had a book to recommend.

Knowlton was a Homecoming queen who married her high school sweetheart and was married for 54 years. 

At her funeral, her son said his mother would have encouraged forgiveness. 

"That's what my mom was about: she was about forgiving,” said Steve Knowlton. “And I think we need to be about forgiving."

Other Investigations:

The investigation into the death of Mary Knowlton was not the first for which Coel was investigated in his career at the Punta Gorda Police Department, which began March 17, 2014.

In October 2015, he was investigated - and cleared - for using excessive force after stopping a man riding a bicycle without a light. Coel said the man resisted arrest, so he released his K9 on the man.

That man's lawyer said video of the incident showed his client was not resisting, and his client spent 11 days in the hospital with injuries from that incident. Even though the department cleared Coel, it said he used "poor decision making" during the incident, and the department changed policies surrounding the use of K9s.

Up Next:

Up Next

  • Punta Gorda officer, police chief charged in citizen academy shooting death
  • Reward increased for suspect wanted for 16-year-old's murder
  • Florida eagles take turns incubating new egg
  • Florida man wanted for murder could be 'anywhere'
  • Crocodile captured on South Florida beach
  • Manhunt for three escaped Florida inmates continues
  • Holidays arrive at Universal Studios Orlando
  • Florida Democratic chairman resigns after disclosures
  • Suspected car thief arrested after being tracked by K-9
  • Search for escaped inmates in Florida panhandle