Collector giving up 3-million baseball card collection

- After nearly 60 years, the collector who spent a lifetime accumulating three million baseball cards -- weighing five tons -- says it's time to say goodbye to his prized possessions.  Soon, each and every card will be up for auction, but he says it was a hard decision to make.

Jeff Matthews knows more than a thing or two about baseball. In 1959, he bought his first baseball card.  He lived in Europe while his father was in the Air Force. Whenever they came home he bought every single card he could get his hands on.

His cards became a lifelong passion.

“As a kid, I learned all mathematics by doing percentages through baseball cards. I learned geography through baseball cards. I looked up where they lived,” Matthews said.

His collection grew so much he had to build an upstairs and downstairs room to hold all three million.

“Out of the three million that I owned, maybe 500,000 were completely different cards,” he said.

But 60 years later, he says he realized the cards that once attracted so many kids were now losing their biggest fans.

“Baseball cards have lost their allure for the younger generation. That's really what made it exciting for me. When I could give kids their favorite player and see them light up, that's really what is fun. That is the best gas I could have,” Matthews said. “I have two girls. I don't see grandsons anywhere in the near future so my logic was, 10 years from now, I’m the only person who knows anything about these cards.”

After a long, painful debate, he decided to box up his collection and send them to a baseball auctioneer.

His favorites are Mickey Mantle and Derek Jeter. Those cards will stay with Matthews. He’s also keeping a pack from 1965 that’s never been opened.

The rest will soon be in the hands of other fans, who Matthews hopes aren't in it for the money, but in it for the love of the game.

“I would love to see it go to someone who is a collector who has that same passion,” he said.

The cards will be up for auction in about five months.

Up Next:


Up Next

  • Collector giving up 3-million baseball card collection
  • Expert: Lots of possible causes for dead crabs in bay
  • Frostproof man accused of sex battery had dozens of child porn imagery, deputies say
  • Man in jail for not unlocking phone could soon be released
  • Case of measles reported in Pinellas County
  • Multiple Polk County school buses delayed on first day of school
  • Too busy to drive to the gas station? There's an app for that
  • St. Pete police search for suspect in failed Cracker Barrel robbery
  • 11th dolphin found dead, red tide suspected
  • Habitat Hillsborough reverses on mortgage sales