MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN - JULY 14: Turning Point USA Founder Charlie Kirk is seen onstage at the Fiserv Forum during preparations for the Republican National Convention (RNC) on July 14, 2024, in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Delegates, politicians, and the Rep …
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. - After a contentious debate, the Republican-controlled House voted along party lines Wednesday on bills that designates a road in Miami-Dade County and a day annually after slain conservative activist Charlie Kirk.
Republicans claimed Kirk was "effective" in teaching people how to civilly engage others. Democrats said Kirk repeatedly expressed racist and misogynist views.
PREVIOUS: Charlie Kirk to receive posthumous Presidential Medal of Freedom
The backstory:
Kirk, the 31-year-old founder of the conservative group Turning Point USA, and an ally of President Donald Trump, was killed on Sept. 10 during a speech at an outdoor rally at Utah Valley University. The 22-year-old suspect in his killing, Tyler Robinson, faces the death penalty if convicted.
Kirk, who grew up in Illinois, reportedly owned a condo in Longboat Key.
What we know:
Under the bill, October 14 – Kirk’s birthday - would be known as "Charlie Kirk Day of Remembrance" each year.
The road measure designates a portion of S.W. 107th Avenue in Miami-Dade County as "Charlie Kirk Memorial Avenue" (HB 33).
The other side:
Rep. Bruce Antone, an Orlando Democrat who is Black, said days of remembrance should be assigned to people and groups that have a history of achievements.
"I just don't know why we are honoring somebody who had no accomplishments, who hadn’t done anything, and who denigrated people that look like me," Antone said.
READ: What is Turning Point USA? Charlie Kirk's nonprofit
Rep. Michele Rayner, D-St. Petersburg, argued state honors should reflect "shared progress, not ideological symbolism."
"As a Black woman serving in this chamber, I cannot overlook the way (Kirk’s) rhetoric has targeted and dismissed Black women and other marginalized voices, including members yelling at other Black women on this floor," Rayner said.
What they're saying:
Port Orange Republican Rep. Chase Tramont countered that Kirk’s words are often taken out of context.
"I can go down a list of misquotes, some fabrications and outright distortions and lies that have been attributed to Charlie Kirk," Tramont said. "But the truth is, I don't really think that would matter, because if we're being truly honest here, this isn't about a personality problem. It's about what it's always about: This is about ideological intolerance, because the same things that people have said about Charlie Kirk are the same things that people say about me and other members in our party."
PREVIOUS: Charlie Kirk to receive posthumous Presidential Medal of Freedom
Rep. Dean Black, R-Jacksonville, added that Kirk’s achievement was as a "debater."
"While people may have disagreed with what he said, he made no attempt to cancel the words of others," Black said.
Marco Island Republican Rep. Yvette Benarroch said her bill establishing a day of remembrance (HB 125) for Kirk was for someone who encouraged a generation to "read the Constitution and love this great country" and was killed exercising his First Amendment rights.
"This bill recognizes that moment and affirms something foundational, that free speech under our Constitution must be protected, even when it is controversial, even when it is unpopular, and even when we disagree," Benarroch said.
Dig deeper:
The House road designation bill also would name a section of Commercial Boulevard in Broward County as "President Donald J. Trump Boulevard."
The Senate version of the road designation bill (SB 194) does not include the road naming for Trump. However, the House did add a provision Wednesday to a transportation bill (SB 628) that would name State Road 80, which runs 124 miles from Palm Beach County to Lee County, after Trump.
Jacksonville Democratic Rep. Angie Nixon said Republicans were rushing to dedicate roads and other facilities after Trump to score "cheap political points."
READ: Charlie Kirk's death highlights rise in political violence: 'It's affecting Americans'
Rep. Juan Carlos Porras, R-Miami, described Kirk as a "modern day civil rights leader," with whom he bonded while forming a Turning Point USA chapter at Florida International University a decade ago.
Republican legislators last week approved a proposal that affixes Trump’s name to Palm Beach International Airport (HB 919).
The Charlie Kirk Day of Remembrance bill was approved in an 82-31 party line vote.
The House voted 82-30 on the Charlie Kirk road dedication.
What's next:
The airport bill, which also preempts naming rights at other major airports in Florida to the state, awaits delivery to Gov. Ron DeSantis.
Both Kirk proposals await Senate action.
The Source: This article was written with information gathered by the News Service of Florida.