3 residents of The Villages cast multiple votes in 2020 election, police say

Three voters from a Florida retirement community that is a GOP stronghold have been arrested on charges of voting more than once. The arrests come weeks after Republican Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis pledged to create a law enforcement agency to investigate election crimes, despite there being little evidence of electoral malfeasance in the Sunshine State.

The three voters — all residents of The Villages area — were arrested over the past two weeks. They were each charged with casting more than one ballot in the 2020 election after complaints were filed by the Sumter County supervisor of elections.

Jay Ketcik 63, was arrested last week on a charge of third-degree felony fraud. He entered a not guilty plea, and court records show he intends to "attack the sufficiency of the charge." 

Joan Halstead, 71, was arrested two weeks ago for voting in-person in Florida and by absentee ballot in New York during the 2020 election, according to an arrest report. She has entered a not guilty plea and also said in court papers she intends to attack "the sufficiency" of the charge.

John Rider, 61, was arrested at the beginning of the month on a similar charge. An arrest report did not say why he was facing the charge. There was no online docket in Sumter County yet for Rider, who was arrested in Brevard County, so it was not known if he had an attorney. No phone number was listed on an arrest report.

Online records show Ketcik and Halstead are registered Republicans, while Rider has no party affiliation.

The arrests come weeks after DeSantis proposed new restrictions on ballot drop boxes, creating a 52-member election police force costing $5.7 million, and changes that would strengthen penalties for ballot harvesting. 

"We will have sworn law enforcement officers as part of this. We'll have investigators. We'll have the statewide prosecutors that are able to bring the cases," said Governor DeSantis. "The first person that gets caught, no one's going to want to do it again after that, because they know that there's going to be enforcement."

During his announcement, DeSantis echoed many talking points on voting problems that have gained traction in the GOP following former President Donald Trump’s false claims that his reelection was stolen from him. DeSantis is up for reelection next year and is eyeing a 2024 presidential run.

The governor had previously praised the 2020 election in Florida as smooth, and there was widespread consensus among election officials and experts that there was no fraud that could have affected results in the last presidential election.

RELATED: Far too little vote fraud to tip 2020 election to Trump, AP review finds

An Associated Press review of every potential case of voter fraud in the six battleground states disputed by Trump has found fewer than 475 — a number that would have made no difference in the 2020 presidential election.

Prior to the 2020 election, Florida took steps to reduce the potential for fraudulent votes. In 2019, Florida joined a collation of 30 states in the Electronic Registration Information Center to share and match data to improve voter list accuracy.

FOX 13 has investigated for voter fraud in prior years, and have found cases do occur but are exceedingly rare. In 2015, a joint investigation between FOX 13 Tampa Bay and FOX 35 Orlando uncovered isolated cases of people voting in Florida and North Carolina in the same presidential election.

FROM 2015: NC prosecutes Florida man for voter fraud following FOX 13 investigation

In separate investigations, one study identified 491 instances out of billions of votes cast. The Electronic Registration Information Center identified 372 possible cases out of about 14.6 million. If all the possible cases were in fact fraud, it would still only represent 0.0025 percent of the returns.

Information from the Associated Press was used in this report.